Average Rent and Home Prices in Shively, KY

A couple stands in their new empty house in Shively, KY, holding keys and smiling.
For many, a new home in Shively represents the start of an exciting chapter and the opportunity to build a future in an affordable, welcoming community.

The Housing Market in Shively Today

The rental market in Shively has seen a 5% increase in average rent prices over the past year, reflecting a tightening of available inventory. Despite this upward trend, Shively still offers a range of housing options to fit various budgets and lifestyles.

New apartment developments are rising in the city center, offering modern amenities and green spaces. These complexes tend to command higher rents but appeal to young professionals seeking walkability and convenience. In contrast, the surrounding neighborhoods feature a mix of older apartment buildings and single-family homes at more affordable price points.

Shively’s proximity to Louisville and its diverse job market continues to attract residents, putting pressure on the housing supply. However, the city’s ongoing efforts to balance growth with affordability have helped maintain a stable market overall.

Renting in Shively: What’s Typical?

For renters in Shively, the average monthly rent for a 1-bedroom apartment is around $850, while a 2-bedroom unit typically costs $1,100. These prices can vary depending on the apartment’s age, amenities, and location within the city.

Young professionals and small families are drawn to the Dixie Highway corridor, where many apartment complexes are located. This area offers easy access to shopping, dining, and public transit. Rent prices here are generally in line with the city average.

Those seeking more affordable options often look to neighborhoods like Pleasure Ridge Park, where older apartment buildings and single-family homes are available for rent. While further from the city center, these areas still provide a strong sense of community and access to parks and schools.

Owning a Home in Shively

The median home price in Shively is $180,000, making it an attractive option for first-time buyers and those looking to escape rising rent prices. With a 10% down payment and a 30-year fixed mortgage at 3.5% interest, the estimated monthly mortgage payment for a median-priced home would be around $1,200.

In addition to the mortgage, homeowners in Shively can expect to pay property taxes averaging 0.85% of the home’s assessed value. This equates to approximately $1,530 per year for a median-priced home. Homeowners insurance typically runs around $1,000 annually, while utility costs average $200 per month.

Some neighborhoods in Shively have homeowners associations (HOAs) that charge monthly or annual dues. These fees, which can range from $100 to $300 per month, often cover amenities like community pools, parks, and exterior maintenance.

Renters vs. Homeowners: Who Lives Where?

Shively has a homeownership rate of 60%, slightly lower than the national average. This is due in part to the city’s younger population and the prevalence of apartment living.

Younger residents, including singles and couples without children, tend to rent apartments in the city center or along major thoroughfares like Dixie Highway. These areas offer a more urban lifestyle with walkable access to amenities.

Families and older residents are more likely to own homes in Shively’s residential neighborhoods. These areas feature a mix of single-family homes, townhouses, and duplexes, often with yards and garages. While some older residents have lived in their homes for decades, the city’s affordability also attracts younger families looking to buy their first home.

Table: Typical Monthly Housing Costs in Shively

Here’s what housing costs might look like each month in Shively:

CostApartment (1BR)House (Median Price)
Rent/Mortgage$850$1,200
Property Tax$130
Utilities$150$200
Insurance$15 (renters)$85 (homeowners)
HOA$150
Total$1,015$1,765

Estimates reflect mid-range properties and average usage.

What’s Driving Costs Up or Down?

Several factors influence housing costs in Shively, with supply and demand playing a significant role. As more people move to the area for work or to escape rising costs in nearby Louisville, competition for available homes and apartments increases, driving up prices.

Shively’s growing job market, particularly in healthcare and logistics, is another factor pushing housing costs higher. As more employers set up shop in the area, the demand for nearby housing grows, putting upward pressure on rents and home prices.

On the supply side, Shively has seen an increase in new apartment construction in recent years, particularly in the city center. While these developments help meet some of the demand, they also tend to command higher rents due to their modern amenities and prime locations.

Zoning and land use policies also play a role in Shively’s housing market. The city has worked to balance the need for growth with the desire to preserve green spaces and single-family neighborhoods. This has limited the amount of high-density housing that can be built, which can contribute to higher costs.

FAQs About Housing in Shively

  • Is Shively affordable to live in? Compared to nearby Louisville, Shively offers a more affordable cost of living, particularly when it comes to housing. The city’s median home price and average rents are lower than in many parts of Louisville, making it an attractive option for those looking to stretch their housing budget.
  • Why are housing prices changing? Housing prices in Shively are influenced by a combination of factors, including population growth, job market trends, and the balance of supply and demand. As more people move to the area and compete for available homes and apartments, prices tend to rise.
  • How does Shively compare to nearby cities? Shively offers a more affordable housing market than many nearby cities, particularly Louisville. However, it also provides a unique blend of urban amenities and suburban charm that appeals to a wide range of residents.

Making Smart Housing Decisions in Shively

When deciding whether to rent or buy in Shively, it’s important to consider your long-term goals and financial situation. Renting offers flexibility and lower upfront costs, but homeownership can provide stability and the opportunity to build equity over time.

For those looking to create a monthly budget, housing costs will likely be the largest expense. Be sure to factor in not just rent or mortgage payments, but also utilities, insurance, and any HOA fees.

It’s also worth exploring the overall cost of living in Shively beyond just housing. The city’s affordability extends to other areas like groceries, transportation, and healthcare, making it an attractive option for those looking to make their budget go further.

Ultimately, whether you choose to rent an apartment or buy a house in Shively, it’s important to do your research and weigh your options carefully. By understanding the local housing market and your own needs and budget, you can make a smart decision that sets you up for long-term financial success.